Nice subject and composition. Excellent color mapping on the rocks. Works wonders with Sonshine777's wet/dry shader - creating the illusion of algal growth on the underwater portion of the rocks. This is very convincing indeed. The texturing is much better on your latest image. This conveys a more natural feeling of age and weathering on the surface of the stones. I have to agree with Calico though. Several of the above-water rocks have troubling geometry to them. I Just don't see this formation of rock occur naturally, especially given its immediate environment. This causes a slight disconnect from what i find otherwise to be a very aesthetically pleasing and convincing image. Nice work!