On Edge

[FrankB]

Frank, I think I pointed out one in one image, but missed the thirteen that you thought were glaring out at everyone in the same image.

SILENCE! <high pitch> I **** you! </high pitch> 

[Henry Blewer]

 

[Linda McCarthy]

Hi Mark,
I happen to love this picture, especially the rock texture, lighting, clarity, contrast and mood.
No accounting for taste, I guess.
Linda

[Markal]

hmm....

having thought about this really, really hard, I can't seem recall a single image I posted on this forum, where nobody had pointed out an obvious mistake if there was one.   

O.K. FrankB...but I don't believe any of your critics re-posted your image with their critiques highlighted!!!.  My image that I worked long and hard on is now a poster child for what not to do...even though I still think it looks O.K. To say or write something looks wrong is not so bad....but to repost the image with the area highlighted I think takes it a bit far...thats all....I'm not a whiner nor am I offended by critiques...I've said enough....the more I say the more misunderstood I get....sorry to bring this all up in the first place.

[Henry Blewer]

I hope you continue to share your work with us here. Not many of use use image maps on the terrain. I tied once and could not get it right. John (Schmeerlap) is very good doing this. But he makes mistakes sometimes also doing this.

I have a feeling that before long you will be doing this technique flawlessly. It is not an easy method to use; you have really done a fine job.

[schmeerlap]

John (Schmeerlap) . . . . . . makes mistakes sometimes also doing this.

Absolutely. I've posted lots of images that "looked ok" to me, that had glaring faults pointed out to me (perhaps not graphically) and were subsequently downgraded (in my mind) to how-not-to-do-its. 
No, no, no John: flawed masterpieces: please. 

John