Fair enough guys.
But I challenge everyone reading this with such strong views as andrew to make something better.
Make a film or video that tells a complete self contained story in 10 min or less, having both an original idea, and a style that distinguishes the work from nearly anyone else's. Do it in one semester (14 weeks) Write, produce, animate, post, and edit it by your self. And then direct and implement an original score.
And when your done put it up in public to be scrutinized by andrew march.
We can compare the two shorts and see which one shows which artist demonstrates the better understanding of story- telling and film making in all of their facets.
No? Ok, I didn't think so.