I obviously have opinions on this topic
. But I actually -do not- agree with the OP.
What the OP describes is basically what we do here every single day. A contest IMO should be special. Besides that, I feel like TG was not created to live in a vacuum, that it was meant to be used with other software, and that in general there is not enough of that in image sharing.
Anyway, I am trying different things too. But right now I feel like my best stuff for the contest so far is the stuff where I only used TG. I don't find after a few years now that having other soft necessarily makes me more successful. Just depends on what I'm trying to make I think.
But what do you mean you are not participating, OP? I saw your thread in the contest page, and I, as well as several others, said that they liked where it was going. Do you think we are pretending? Don't loose your nerve man! Work it until it is done, you clearly had a vision.
Besides all that, I doubt very much that Matt and the others are going to be distracted by flash. I think they all know what a good idea and composition look like. And there is not just 1 winner. There are three winners. And I doubt that 1st place will go to the best use of WM or GC2 or whatever. I really think its about how you use TG to realize an idea, regardless of if you used other soft or not.
Lastly, I find that you really have to know TG well to use it in a good way with other soft. So someone who knows TG that well is likely to win anyway (regardless of other soft), which is how it would be in any medium I would think. I would expect that the winners and in general the best images will show a good understanding of the software, just as we see in image sharing everyday.
No?