Quote from: Mohawk20 on April 11, 2009, 06:44:48 PM
Actually, TG was doing pretty good in realism some 5 years ago...
I remember printing some TG 0.9 renders as photographs (had to go to a store to do that back then). Everyone who saw them thought they were photo's. Though if you see those renders now everyone would see they are clearly CG.
Yes indeed. Although...I left some prints at my parents place and they are at the wall in the visitor's room and all of them still think it are photographs. To me/us they would look very CG'ish
Quote from: normhol on April 11, 2009, 09:37:14 PM
From a newbies point of view...cudos to PorkupineFloyd. Let not one's "EGO" conflict with another's "EGO", but enjoy what you have created. If it is pleasing to you and others have enjoyed it as well...GREAT!.
Now..if you are asking for opinions of the "learned" on this forum, then that is different.
To the "learned" ones, perhaps it would be more helpful, rather than telling WHAT could be done to improve the render, but tell HOW it can be to accomplished.
I believe some of the critiques could be greatly improved and not seem so "critical".
Cheers,
Norm.
I agree, fun is at first place and as I also enjoy creating images I also enjoy sharing them to receive critiques for improvements.
Which brings me to the second part of your post, because I think many of you consider me to be one of the "learned" ones and honestly I do consider it a bit myself as well
lol
I do not really feel addressed by your feelings, because I think I can say with a clear sense of honesty I always try to give as much advice as possible how to actually achieve the suggestions for improvement I make. So I do not feel being "attacked" in any sense, but I certainly understand your feelings.
When I was a beginner and still had much to learn I sometimes also received suggestions for improvements but not for an approach to achieve it and also found that a bit annoying from time to time.
What I do miss sometimes though is the initiative of the user to ask straight away how to do it.
I realize the importance of good feedback because it improved my work and also therefore increased my joy in creating images I wouldn't dream of creating them some time ago.
So for everyone: if you feel like you need more explanation on critiques and especially on how to get it look better, just ask
Martin